Power of the Middle Indian
By Chandan Mitra
Agenda
The Pioneer
Sunday, June 5, 2011
Agenda
The Pioneer
Sunday, June 5, 2011
Baba Ramdev has energised India's small towns into vocally demanding
equality of opportunity with the metropolitan elite: It's a genie
that won't go back into the bottle
equality of opportunity with the metropolitan elite: It's a genie
that won't go back into the bottle
Television has changed the way we live, even think: Now religion and
spirituality too are conditioned by what preachers declaim on the
audio-visual media. In the US, TV evangelists spawned the emergence
of the Religious Right, which supplanted the erstwhile Moral
Majority. Both were conservative, suspicious of left/liberal support
for gay rights or abortion, committed to upholding family values and
broadly Republican in their political preference. As an industry, TV
evangelism boomed during the late 1980s and 1990s, although the
reported misdemeanours of some celebrity preachers have eroded the
popularity of this genre.
spirituality too are conditioned by what preachers declaim on the
audio-visual media. In the US, TV evangelists spawned the emergence
of the Religious Right, which supplanted the erstwhile Moral
Majority. Both were conservative, suspicious of left/liberal support
for gay rights or abortion, committed to upholding family values and
broadly Republican in their political preference. As an industry, TV
evangelism boomed during the late 1980s and 1990s, although the
reported misdemeanours of some celebrity preachers have eroded the
popularity of this genre.
Social or political reform, however, was not prominent on their
agenda. They focussed on moral issues with faith healing as the main
crowd puller. Christian preachers, mostly foreigners, have sought to
replicate this model in India, particularly in the southern States.
They have in turn influenced many Hindu cult leaders as well, who
hold huge camps across the country to sermonise and promote
Munnabhai-type cures for ailments. The rise of TV gurus, who appear
regularly on various 24/7 religious channels that have mushroomed,
has significantly altered not just thought processes but also
impacted people's lifestyles.
agenda. They focussed on moral issues with faith healing as the main
crowd puller. Christian preachers, mostly foreigners, have sought to
replicate this model in India, particularly in the southern States.
They have in turn influenced many Hindu cult leaders as well, who
hold huge camps across the country to sermonise and promote
Munnabhai-type cures for ailments. The rise of TV gurus, who appear
regularly on various 24/7 religious channels that have mushroomed,
has significantly altered not just thought processes but also
impacted people's lifestyles.
It is on the crest of India's massive pravachan industry that Baba
Ramdev holds sway over a significant section. Unlike many of his
compatriots, the muscular Haryanvi swami is not essentially a
philosopher. He is a doer more than a thinker, delivering crisp
messages on the applicability of religious texts to everyday life.
Baba Ramdev's appeal derives from his mastery over Yog, which he
popularises as a panacea for almost every illness. He claims he can
cure cancer and AIDS too with his unique formula that entails
practice of Yog alongside a special diet whose ingredients too his
Patanjali group has to provide. In less than a decade, the Patanjali
Yogashram has built a huge network of outlets for its organic food
products and beverages that are prescribed by ayurvedic practitioners
stationed at these outlets.
Ramdev holds sway over a significant section. Unlike many of his
compatriots, the muscular Haryanvi swami is not essentially a
philosopher. He is a doer more than a thinker, delivering crisp
messages on the applicability of religious texts to everyday life.
Baba Ramdev's appeal derives from his mastery over Yog, which he
popularises as a panacea for almost every illness. He claims he can
cure cancer and AIDS too with his unique formula that entails
practice of Yog alongside a special diet whose ingredients too his
Patanjali group has to provide. In less than a decade, the Patanjali
Yogashram has built a huge network of outlets for its organic food
products and beverages that are prescribed by ayurvedic practitioners
stationed at these outlets.
Meanwhile the Baba's popularity has surged phenomenally, thanks to
his early morning yog expositions on TV. A talkative man whom BJP
president Nitin Gadkari somewhat cheekily called the "rock star of
yog", the Baba expounds on various domestic and international issues.
He promotes restructuring of India's educational and agricultural
system with simplistic but appealing notions like technical courses
being taught in the mother tongue or organic farming with drip
irrigation. The semi-urban (small town) Indian middle class, left out
of the zooming growth curve of the English-speaking, West-oriented
metropolitan elite, eagerly laps up these "solutions".
his early morning yog expositions on TV. A talkative man whom BJP
president Nitin Gadkari somewhat cheekily called the "rock star of
yog", the Baba expounds on various domestic and international issues.
He promotes restructuring of India's educational and agricultural
system with simplistic but appealing notions like technical courses
being taught in the mother tongue or organic farming with drip
irrigation. The semi-urban (small town) Indian middle class, left out
of the zooming growth curve of the English-speaking, West-oriented
metropolitan elite, eagerly laps up these "solutions".
Here lies the fundamental difference between Baba Ramdev and the rest
of his tribe. The others, many of them early movers in the TV race
like Morari Bapu, Asaram Bapu, Sudhanshu Maharaj, Ma Anandamoyee,
Mata Amritanandamayi, focus on the individual. They sermonise on
morality, healthy lifestyle, relevance of religion in today's
material world, meditation and so on, aimed at providing salvation to
the individual, Sri Sri Ravishankar branched out to build his own
model, part-individual, part-collective by organising yog-cum-
meditation camps of diverse sizes to promote what he named the Art of
Living. An engaging speaker, Sri Sri's appeal too grew rapidly and
his command over the English language enabled him to spread his
message globally.
of his tribe. The others, many of them early movers in the TV race
like Morari Bapu, Asaram Bapu, Sudhanshu Maharaj, Ma Anandamoyee,
Mata Amritanandamayi, focus on the individual. They sermonise on
morality, healthy lifestyle, relevance of religion in today's
material world, meditation and so on, aimed at providing salvation to
the individual, Sri Sri Ravishankar branched out to build his own
model, part-individual, part-collective by organising yog-cum-
meditation camps of diverse sizes to promote what he named the Art of
Living. An engaging speaker, Sri Sri's appeal too grew rapidly and
his command over the English language enabled him to spread his
message globally.
It is difficult to say why and exactly when Baba Ramdev forayed out
of conventional models of the yog-pravachan industry to build his
unique brand of socially relevant sermonising. His declared agenda
has very little to do with yog or spirituality except in the remote
sense of using these instruments to build a healthier nation and
purify human beings both internally and externally. Probably, Ramdev
himself has not yet figured out a clear-cut road map. But the way
people have responded to his anti-corruption message must be giving
him ideas on how to expand his influence beyond that of a yog
preacher.
of conventional models of the yog-pravachan industry to build his
unique brand of socially relevant sermonising. His declared agenda
has very little to do with yog or spirituality except in the remote
sense of using these instruments to build a healthier nation and
purify human beings both internally and externally. Probably, Ramdev
himself has not yet figured out a clear-cut road map. But the way
people have responded to his anti-corruption message must be giving
him ideas on how to expand his influence beyond that of a yog
preacher.
He launched a nationwide movement one year ago, calling it Bharat
Swabhiman Yatra to trudge across 100,000 km in a bid to rouse people
out of their inertia on nation-building. The move invited scepticism;
his detractors said that the ambitious Baba was planning to encash
his mass appeal to launch himself in politics. Indeed he has
contradicted himself on occasion, first saying he would launch a
political party and contest elections but later retracting to insist
he has no political ambitions. Possibly the current anti-politician
mood among the middle class has made him wary.
Swabhiman Yatra to trudge across 100,000 km in a bid to rouse people
out of their inertia on nation-building. The move invited scepticism;
his detractors said that the ambitious Baba was planning to encash
his mass appeal to launch himself in politics. Indeed he has
contradicted himself on occasion, first saying he would launch a
political party and contest elections but later retracting to insist
he has no political ambitions. Possibly the current anti-politician
mood among the middle class has made him wary.
Runaway corruption in the UPA Government, particularly the staggering
estimates of loss to the exchequer in the 2G Spectrum scam, which
came to light in a big way earlier this year, created the ideal
ground for non-political freelancers, some with personal agendas.
Baba Ramdev had not seriously politicised his appeal till Anna
Hazare's agitation for enactment of a Lok Pal Bill caught the
nation's imagination. Although it was the Baba's financial clout and
manpower reserves that helped Anna's cohorts galvanise young people
across the country, he was shrewdly sidelined by the urbane core
group, which had no time for saffron-robed swamijis.
estimates of loss to the exchequer in the 2G Spectrum scam, which
came to light in a big way earlier this year, created the ideal
ground for non-political freelancers, some with personal agendas.
Baba Ramdev had not seriously politicised his appeal till Anna
Hazare's agitation for enactment of a Lok Pal Bill caught the
nation's imagination. Although it was the Baba's financial clout and
manpower reserves that helped Anna's cohorts galvanise young people
across the country, he was shrewdly sidelined by the urbane core
group, which had no time for saffron-robed swamijis.
Anna Hazare may have inspired large sections of the metropolitan
chatterati and glitterati into expressing sudden concern over the
culture of corruption (from which they have significantly benefited),
but the Jantar-Mantar protest left the burgeoning Indian small towns
untouched. That is the vast reservoir which Ramdev is hoping to
mobilise. This is not to suggest that the Yog guru lacks support in
the metros, but his followers are drawn mainly from the non-English
speaking lower middle class who are in reality the biggest sufferers
from the cancer of corruption. They emotionally supported Anna
Hazare's drive to install a tough anti-corruption regime through the
institution of Lok Pal, but neither did they understand the legal
intricacies that involves, nor did they seriously believe that a Lok
Pal alone would lead to the collapse of the edifice of venality.
chatterati and glitterati into expressing sudden concern over the
culture of corruption (from which they have significantly benefited),
but the Jantar-Mantar protest left the burgeoning Indian small towns
untouched. That is the vast reservoir which Ramdev is hoping to
mobilise. This is not to suggest that the Yog guru lacks support in
the metros, but his followers are drawn mainly from the non-English
speaking lower middle class who are in reality the biggest sufferers
from the cancer of corruption. They emotionally supported Anna
Hazare's drive to install a tough anti-corruption regime through the
institution of Lok Pal, but neither did they understand the legal
intricacies that involves, nor did they seriously believe that a Lok
Pal alone would lead to the collapse of the edifice of venality.
Hence the full-throated demand for "systemic change". Ramdev is
selling the big picture as opposed to the Anna Hazare party's narrow-
focussed campaign. The Baba's slogans are simple and seem to be quite
the panacea: Get back Rs 400 lakh crore of black money stashed
abroad, hang those found guilty of corruption, drastically amend the
political system to bring about a Presidential form of Government,
teach engineering and medicine in the mother tongue to unleash the
latent talent of Middle India.
selling the big picture as opposed to the Anna Hazare party's narrow-
focussed campaign. The Baba's slogans are simple and seem to be quite
the panacea: Get back Rs 400 lakh crore of black money stashed
abroad, hang those found guilty of corruption, drastically amend the
political system to bring about a Presidential form of Government,
teach engineering and medicine in the mother tongue to unleash the
latent talent of Middle India.
To the seasoned (or cynical) observer this is a mere wish list,
easier propagated than done. Getting back money from tax havens is an
arduous, complex job that even the powerful US Administration has not
succeeded in doing. Besides, much of the illicit money stashed abroad
must have been taken out of foreign banks and brought to India
through hawala transactions. But it is not concrete accomplishment
that will determine the Baba's growth trajectory; it is faith and
hope. It is the dream that Middle India would like to hang on to. It
is the belief that a missionary crusader will ensure equal
opportunities to Middle India's children and help brighten their
futures, deliver them from the domination of the metropolitan elite
that is propelling Baba's campaign. May be the dream will get
betrayed. On the other hand, may be some good will come out of it.
easier propagated than done. Getting back money from tax havens is an
arduous, complex job that even the powerful US Administration has not
succeeded in doing. Besides, much of the illicit money stashed abroad
must have been taken out of foreign banks and brought to India
through hawala transactions. But it is not concrete accomplishment
that will determine the Baba's growth trajectory; it is faith and
hope. It is the dream that Middle India would like to hang on to. It
is the belief that a missionary crusader will ensure equal
opportunities to Middle India's children and help brighten their
futures, deliver them from the domination of the metropolitan elite
that is propelling Baba's campaign. May be the dream will get
betrayed. On the other hand, may be some good will come out of it.
But whatever happens, Middle India has served notice on the ruling
elite: They can no longer be ignored or deprived of the opportunities
their urban counterparts have grabbed for themselves over the last 64
years.
elite: They can no longer be ignored or deprived of the opportunities
their urban counterparts have grabbed for themselves over the last 64
years.
No comments:
Post a Comment